Posts Tagged ‘Lok Sabha’

The Report Card on Vote Report India Version 1.0

Friday, May 15th, 2009

Vote Report India Banner

The 2009 Indian Lok Sabha elections have come to an end and so has version 1.0 of Vote Report India.

We have had our successes and failures and I have talked about some of them before.

I think we did a lot of things well –

- We were able to get the website up within a week, thank to some great work by the Ushahidi and eMoksha teams.

- We were able to build a number of important relationship, with civil society organizations (like Jaago Re/ One Billion Voters, National Network for India, Liberty Institute, Citizens for Justice and Peace, and Women’s Political Forum), traditional media organizations (like Al Jazeera) and new media organizations (like Global Voices, Indipepal, Desipundit, BlogAdda, NGO Post and Digital Democracy). In fact, our partnerships page looks like a literal who’s who of the important players working on the Indian elections.

- We were able to generate a lot of buzz for Vote Report India, on blogs, on Twitter, and in mainstream media within a very short time.

- We have been able to build a vibrant Vote Report India community that has been active in supporting us on both the technical and outreach side.

Here are some things that have not gone well –

- We haven’t been able to establish a relationship with any big Indian media organizations on one hand, and National election Watch and the Election Commission on the other hand, in spite of some serious discussions.

- We haven’t been able to integrate the Swift functionality into Vote Report India (aggregating feeds from multiple sources and crowdsourcing the tagging etc.) on our original timelines.

- We haven’t been able to get users to submit reports in large numbers. We have a little more than 200 reports in the system, which isn’t bad. However, we would have needed many more reports to capture the complexity of the 2009 Indian elections.

- The voter turnout in all four phases has been low, putting a question mark on the effectiveness of all digital civil society campaigns like Vote Report India.

Here are some lessons from Vote Report India version 1.0 –

- It’s still difficult to build a grassroots movement in India exclusively on the internet. Even online campaigns need to be supported by mainstream media for reach and SMS for the feedback loop. We had SMS, but we didn’t have the resources to advertise on mainstream media.

- In a country like India, which has a free and noisy news eco-system, transparency initiatives like Vote Report India need to not only get original reports from users but also aggregate reports from mainstream media.

- Transparency, in terms of availability of information in a usable format, is not a big enough incentive for Indian users. Users expected Vote Report India to closeloop the issues and give them feedback, and we were not set up to do that.

On the whole, I think that we did quite well, given our time and resource constraints.

Our biggest achievement, I think, was being able to build a vibrant community around Vote Report India and we are grateful for your contribution to the project.

As I said, this was only version 1.0 of Vote Report India. We will take a short break and then relaunch Vote Report India as a platform to crowd-source the performance monitoring of our elected members of parliament, using the Ushahidi/ Swift engines. We will move the present homepage to 2009.votereport.in and start new pages like 2014.votereport.in for new elections, including local assembly elections.

Selvam and I, along with the other members of the core team, will continue to devote a substantial part of our time to Vote Report India. We are looking to expand our team, so do write to us at votereportindia@gmail.com, if you would like to become involved in a significant way.

Once again, thank you for helping Vote Report India make a small difference to the 2009 Indian elections.

Vote Report India Featured in UAE Daily The National

Thursday, April 30th, 2009

Vote Report India was recently featured in UAE daily The National.

Here is the full text of the story –

Website keeps candidates in line

Jonathan Spollen, Assistant Foreign Editor

April 27. 2009 4:00PM UAE / April 27. 2009 12:00PM GMT

The Indian elections have not been short of incident. Varun Gandhi delivered what some say amounted to hate speech, Maoists attacked poll officials in Chhattisgarh, resulting in seven deaths, and Lashkar-i-Taiba, the Pakistani militant group, has threatened violence.

Along with scores of other violations of electoral conduct, from bribery to the theft of voting machines, all were duly noted and posted on Vote Report India, a website dedicated to what it calls “citizen-driven election monitoring”.

The site allows individuals from anywhere in India to report occurrences of misconduct via telephone, e-mail, SMS and blog links, which are then aggregated by the site administrators with news reports, other blog posts, photos, videos and tweets (Twitter messages) of the same incident to verify its truth.

Set up this month before the first phase of voting to “increase transparency and accountability in the Indian election process”, the site receives about 20 reports a day, though this spiked to more than 60 on the first day of voting, April 16.

“We are having a lot of success within the online community. There is a lot of awareness, a lot of people linking to us,” said Gaurav Mishra, 29, a core member of VRI’s 35-person team.

Visitors to the site will find on the home page a map of India scattered with red dots indicating areas where violations have been reported. The bigger the dot, the greater the number of incidents in that particular area or constituency, and clicking on it will bring links to the reports.

Click on the bloated Nagpur, for example, and you will find 12 reports including cases of bribery and the arrest of a Republican Party candidate for using fake documents.

Meanwhile, in the north-eastern state of Manipur, 14 electronic voting machines were snatched during polling, while in the western state of Rajasthan, a BJP leader, Jaswant Singh, was caught on camera handing out money to voters.

Mr Mishra said the most reported violation of electoral conduct so far has been hate speech by candidates against various religions, castes and communities.

To this end he praised the Indian election commission – many of whose reports VRI carries – for being “extremely vigilant” in such cases.

Analysts say VRI and other election-monitoring sites and media are forcing politicians to be more accountable and to think twice about indulging in acts that might be seen as corrupt.

“Politicians are more answerable now,” said Animesh Bhaya, 25, a producer with Star television in New Delhi. “Lots of things used to get covered up, but they are being very cautious now. In the long run [Indian elections] will be more visible.”

An all-volunteer collaboration between software developers, designers, academics and other professionals, the site has been endorsed by four major human rights and pro-democracy groups and has accrued a number of media partners, among them the Global Voices website and Al Jazeera English.

VRI’s work spans India, Africa and the United States, Mr Mishra said. “The goal is to spread beyond this.”

The concept of VRI’s citizen election monitoring, however, comes from the award-winning website Ushahidi.com, which was set up to map reports of post-election violence in Kenya in 2008.

Ushahidi, meaning “testimony” in Swahili, “crowdsources crisis information” using the original platform – citizen reporting via telephone, e-mail, SMS, etc – that VRI now uses.

Indeed, half of the VRI team are also involved in Ushahidi.

Mr Mishra holds a fellowship in communications sponsored by internet giant Yahoo at Georgetown University. He said similar election-monitoring sites are now operating in Congo, South Africa and the Gaza Strip.

His hope is that the number of reports per day will increase as the Indian elections progress.

Mr Bhaya of Star TV has no doubt they will. “More and more people have internet now, and they can [make these reports] from the comfort of their own home,” he said.

“This is making a positive impact.”

jspollen@thenational.ae

The article has a couple of small misquotes. The Vote Report India team is spread across India, Africa and the United States, but our focus is squarely on India. Also, the Ushahidi platform has been implemented in Congo, South Africa and Gaza, but it is the first time it has been used for election monitoring. We are hoping that Ushahidi will be used for election monitoring in several more countries and the Vote Report India experience will be useful in these implementation.

Vote Report India Featured in Indian Daily The Hindu

Saturday, April 25th, 2009

Vote Report India was featured today in Indian daily The Hindu, in a story on the use of internet and mobile technologies in the 2009 Indian Lok Sabha elections.

Here is the full text of the story –

A click away

Sruthi Krishnan and Priscilla Jebaraj

The internet is a mine of information on the polls

You are going to vote but are not sure who the candidates in your constituency are. Or you are not sure where your polling booth is. If you have an internet connection, the answers are just a click away.

VoteIndia (http://voteindia.in), whose motto is ‘Let’s have a meaningful revolution,’ provides information on candidates through emails. Register on the site by providing your email address and loc ate your home on the Google map provided. Once you do this, the site determines your constituency and ward and sends you the relevant information. The site gets this information from the affidavits the candidates file with the Election Commission.

Another site that makes use of Google maps is Vote Report India (http://votereport.in). This monitors news and events related to the elections, aggregates it on an interactive map. For instance, if you want to know where “inflammatory speech” occurred, it would highlight locations such as Kandhamal and Pilibhit.

On Indipepal (http://indipepal.com/politics), you can find the back story of six decades of Indian elections in an accessible graphic format. Whether it’s voter turnout or election expenditure over the years, at the national or State level, or the record of various parties when it comes to women candidates, MPs with criminal records or the extent of participation in Lok Sabha debates, it’s all there. For first-time voters, the site also offers a crash course in Indian political terms and realities.

At http://mibazaar.com/indianpolitics.html, you can find details about the 128 MPs with criminal records, all mapped out on a Google map.

Polling Booth (http://pollingbooth.in) gives you your polling booth information, if you feed it your voter ID details. It is available only for Hyderabad district as of now.

Vote Report India Featured on French News Channel France 24

Friday, April 24th, 2009

French News Channel France 24 recently interviewed me for a TV segment on the use of internet and mobile technologies in the 2009 Indian Lok Sabha elections. We also talked about Vote Report India.

Here’s the link to the original video. Here’s the video on YouTube

Vote Ki Vaat Mat Lagne Do

Thursday, April 23rd, 2009

I am delighted that the wonderfully talented folks at The Comic Project have designed a poster for Vote Report India

Vote Report India Poster by The Comic project

I absolutely love the tag line: “Vote Ki Vaat Mat Lagne Do” (Mumbai-speak for “Don’t Let Them Screw Around With the Vote”).

Please feel free to share the poster on blogs and social networks.

Here are some other election-related posters you must check out at The Comic Project — Shoe Dodging, Congress Poster, BJP Poster, Third Front Poster.

Vote Report India Featured in Indian Daily Mid Day

Thursday, April 23rd, 2009

Vote Report India Mid Day

Indian daily Mid Day did a nice story on Vote Report India today, and even put up my Introduction to Vote Report India video on their website.

Here is the full text of the story –

Don’t just be a voter Now, You Can Also Monitor the Poll Process.

Votereport.in, a first-of-its-kind citizenpowered platform, allows you to highlight irregularities via SMS, email, or even a Tweet
Bhairavi Jhaveri bhairavi.jhaveri@mid-day.com

What could the 26/11 terror attacks, a Kenyan post-election violence blog and one more avid blogger possibly have in common? The mix, as this correspondent discovered, is more potent than you might imagine at first.

Gaurav Mishra (29) was only a Yahoo! Fellow in International Values, Communications, Technology, and Global Internet in Washington until the Mumbai terror attacks. But the tragedy got him toying with the idea of forming a network for the Indian elections along the lines of the Kenyan post-election violence blogger network, Ushahidi.

The aim was to increase transparency and accountability, instill a participatory mindset among citizens and provide a complete picture of public opinion during the 2009 polls.

Armed with these goals and the aid of Internet technologist Selvam Velmurugam (35), Mishra converted his idea into reality on April 6 with the website Vote Report India (VRI). MiD DAY explores the site…
How VRI works?

VRI allows users to report violations of the election code of conduct via SMS, e-mail and online complaints. The platform will compile these with news reports, blog posts, photos, videos and Tweets from all relevant sources on an interactive map.

This means, when you click a point on the VRI map, a timeline of all the incidents related to that location would be displayed.
“We will eventually do an analysis of incidents to present trends as well,” said Gaurav.

The dual approach will up transparency levels in the election process, the founders believe.

A hit already

The duo believes VRI has managed to throw up great numbers since its launch, as it gives the youth the sense that they have the power to create positive change by making the election process transparent. Over 100 blog posts have been linked to the site and it is receiving 1,000+ page views per day. “We hit 60 reports on April 16. The most popular categories are Election Commission Interventions, Voter Bribing and Violence. As of now, most of the stories are based on stories already reported in the media,” says Gaurav.

Mishra and Selvam are confident that VRI will be around for future elections. Meanwhile, they are working on another platform for elections around the world, starting with Lebanon in June.

The team

While Mishra is involved in research on how Internet and mobile technologies transform society, Selvam has founded eMoksha.org, a non-profit organisation aimed at enabling stronger democracies through increased citizen awareness and engagement.

“When I was in India, by elections were being held in parts of Tamil Nadu. I heard friends and relatives complain about not finding their names on the electoral roll, or their vote being cast by someone else. I wondered who they would approach,” says Selvam.

They were supported by 35 other volunteers — with the core team in the US and a handful of partners and local promoters helping them reach out to organisations in India.

The service is powered by Ushahidi and SwiftRiver, and managed by eMoksha. Ushahidi is an award-winning platform that sources citizen reporting. SwiftRiver is a platform that makes sense of multiple sources of information in a fast-changing crisis situation.

VRI has also partnered with the Arabic news network Al Jazeera.
Citizens can send reports via SMS with VoteReport to 5676785, e-mail to report@votereport.in, tweet with the Hastag (#Votereport) or by logging on to www.votereport.in. You can even join the group’s communities on Facebook, Orkut, Twitter (@votereportindia), SMS GupShup or Google Groups.

Video: An Introduction to Vote Report India

Tuesday, April 21st, 2009

Here’s a short video in which I talk about the idea behind Vote Report India, the nice buzz we have generated in the two weeks we have been live, and the challenges and delights of working with a team of 35 volunteers spread across three continents.

Vote Report India Featured in Indian Daily Deccan Herald

Monday, April 20th, 2009

Vote Report India was featured today in a Deccan Herald story on the use of digital technologies in the Indian elections.

Here is the full text of the story –

Campaigning virtually
Click and read
The impact of Internet and mobile technologies on the election campaign has been immense. Metrolife takes a look at the digital initiatives

Most of us at some point or the other have been guilty of whiling away time in front of the social networking sites, exploring profiles with the only legitimate contribution of increasing the hit rate of the sites. But did you ever imagine that the same exercise could end up making us a responsible citizen and an informed voter?
The urban youth is fast taking to the digital media as a means of gathering information on election, so the political parties are pulling up their socks and catering to this cross-section for the month-long general elections to the 15th Lok Sabha.

According to Gaurav Mishra, the co-founder of Vote Report India and also a researcher on Internet and society in emerging countries at Georgetown University, Washington, “This year is primed to be India’s first digital elections as India’s 714 million voters prepare to elect their 543 representatives. They are witness to a range of digital initiatives from political parties, civil society organisations, media houses and even corporates. As a result, some observers are calling it India’s first digital elections. It’s also a test case for the effectiveness of digital technologies in the emerging world.”

Taking the lead is the BJP online initiative through L K Advani, who in his blog, drawing over 150 comments candidly states: “In my own political life spanning six decades, I have enthusiastically embraced every new communication technology — from the early simple Casio digital diary to iPod and iPhone.”

And this phenomenon is giving rise to different aspects of online campaigning that are getting bigger and more intense and definitely more creative.

According to Gaurav’s report, some of the popular online initiatives include Rajesh Jain’s Netcore Solutions, which is running the SMS campaign for the BJP, and has bought an inventory of one billion SMSes for the campaign.

The campaign for Number Criminals in Politics (nocriminals.org) aims to ensure that no political party gives tickets to candidates with criminal antecedents in the 2009 elections. The campaign is effectively using social media
platforms like Facebook and YouTube to spread its message.

Till now, the most successful campaign has been the Jaago Re (jaagore.com) in association with Janaagraha, which started in September 2008 to initiate a voter registration drive in colleges and corporates in 35 cities across the country and to register four million voters.

Says Ashika, involved with Jaago Re and Janaagraha website that does online profiling for candidates standing for election in Bangalore.

“We target urban youth who have access to Internet and SMS and have profiled 85 candidates standing for elections from the three constituencies in Bangalore: North, South and Central, in a very non-partisan way. Not all the candidates have the means to reach out to the public through traditional campaigning, so our website gives all that information including, candidate nomination, assets, criminal records etc.”

And the youth of the City seem to lap it all up. Says Karthik Shetty, a software professional who has been avidly following the elections, “The parties have posted their manifestoes on their websites, which can be read and understood at leisure, making information about their work available on a click.”

The online brouhaha does not end with elections. Many of these web portals are looking at long term transparency and accountability once the government is elected.

Says Gaurav, “Vote Report India (votereport.in) is a collaborative citizen-powered election monitoring platform for the 2009 elections. It aims to not only provide the most complete picture of public opinion in India during the month-long elections, but will also work on increasing transparency and accountability in the Indian election process.”

India’s First Digital Elections Evoke Strong Reactions Online

Friday, April 17th, 2009

The world’s biggest election is underway in India and, as India’s 714 million voters cast their ballots in the month-long elections, they are witness to a range of digital initiatives from political parties, civil society organizations, media houses and even corporates. It’s not surprising, then, that the Indian internet community is abuzz with discussions related to various aspects of the elections.

It’s not only a big election in terms of numbers, it’s a big election for India in terms of timing. Last November, the terrorist attack in Mumbai shook up India’s politically apathetic youngsters and brought them out into the streets. Since then, a series of digital civil society initiatives have sought to channel this newfound sense of civic engagement in the Indian youth into meaningful participation in the political process.

In the run up to the elections, online conversations in India have been charged with this civic consciousness. Transparency campaigns like No Criminals in Politics and Vote Report India and voter registration campaigns like Tata Tea’s Jaago Re have caught the imagination of urban India’s web-savvy youngsters, with their effective use of social media platforms like Facebook and YouTube.

Rashmi Bansal believed that, with the campaign, Tata Tea has taken corporate social responsibility further than most brands do. Rajesh Kumar wondered why only beverage companies do election themed social advertising. Indian Homemaker and Chavvi Sachdev shared their experiences with voter registration. Sanjukta did an interesting interview with Jaago Re campaign coordinator Jasmine Shah.

At the same time, the janus-faced Lead India/ Bleed India campaign by The Times of India has incited mixed reactions.

Anondan tore apart the Lead India print ad while Rajiv Dingra wondered about the rationale behind the Lead India/ Bleed India dichotomy. On Twitter, several users like Deepak and Kanika, found the Bleed India campaign “funny and creative”, while Sumant and Aadisht believed that Bleed India was “buzz gone wrong” and “badly done sarcasm”.

BJP leader Lal Krishna Advani’s Obama-style digital campaign consisting of a blog, a blogger outreach program, and an aggressive internet and mobile advertising element, has also evoked strong reactions online.

Most bloggers, including Sampad Swain, Mayank Dhingra and myself, have praised BJP’s campaign, but some, like blogger-turned columnist Sidin Vadukut have complained that it is an overkill.

The Congress Party’s Bharat Buland campaign, built around the Oscar-winning song Jai Ho (let there be victory) from Slumdog Millionaire, has attracted a lot of criticism from bloggers like Vinod Sharma, especially after the BJP released a parody titled Bhay Ho (let there be fear).

Aparna Ray has captured some of the reactions to the BJP and Congress campaigns in previous posts on Global Voices.

Several bloggers like Rajesh Jain (associated with Friends of BJP), Offstumped are aggressively campaigning for BJP. The #indiavotes09 Twitter feed is dominated by hardcore BJP supporters like @offstumped, @centerofright, and @deadpresident, with only @vimoh and @b50 standing up for Congress.

Beyond the campaigns, bloggers have been critical of BJP’s Hindutva agenda and the Congress party’s obsession with the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. Bhumika Ghimire has written about these critcisms in a previous Global Voices post.

The Indian internet community has also been abuzz with discussions on the controversy surrounding Varun Gandhi’s inflammatory anti-Muslim speech and subsequent imprisonment, the incidents of shoe-throwing against Congress politicians P Chidambambaram and Naveen Jindal and BJP leader L K Advani, and the election campaigns of writer Shashi Tharoor , danseuse Mallika Sarabhai and ABN AMRO India chief Meera Sanyal.

In the midst of this spirit of civic engagement, some people have become fixated on the misguided idea of “negative voting” under section 49(O). Basically, the idea is that voters should have the right to ask for a re-election by selecting a “none of the above” option, if none of the candidates are acceptable to them. A chain e-mail falsely claimed that such a rule already exists. Many bloggers, like Deva Prasad and Vimoh, strongly supported the idea and even called it a powerful agent of change. A Facebook group and an online petition promoting the idea are getting some traction.

In terms of individual sources, the Outlook India Election Blog is doing a great curation role by linking to important stories from elsewhere. Social networking community IndiPepal has blogs from several well-known analysts. Blogger Chakresh Mishra is doing a series of state-wise pre-poll predictions for the Indian elections. Blogger Manoj Kevalramani is traveling through 11 states in 45 days to get a first-hand impression of the mood on the ground during the election period. The Indian Muslims Blog is writing about the elections from a unique minority perspective. Jai Hind, Indian Election 2009, Indian Elections 2009, Indian Elections, Speak India and Youth Ki Awaaz are some other blogs dedicated to election coverage. BlogAdda and OneVote are doing a great job of aggregating these conversations.

Ten Days Into Vote Report India

Thursday, April 16th, 2009

Ten days into Vote Report India, it’s time for a long overdue update on what’s happening behind the scene and under the hood.

Technology/ Design

The tech team is hard at work to fix all the bugs and introduce new features. You should see some significant changes on the front page in a couple of days. Having said that, we are aware that we have a long list of bugs and an even longer wish list on the Open Tech Projects page on the project wiki. If you have found a bug that’s not listed on that page, or want to suggest a new feature, please add it there directly or write an email to Selvam (selvam.velmurugan@gmail.com). We can also do with half a dozen extra hands on the design/ coding side, so if you want to help, or know someone who does, write to Selvam (selvam.velmurugan@gmail.com) immediately.

Reporting Incidents

We had close to 30 reports during the first phase of the elections, including some direct SMS and email reports. This is a little disappointing, but not really unexpected. The key, then, is to seed the system by manually entering reports ourselves. The easiest way to do it is from the Newsrack dashboard that Subramanya has especially created for us. Our reports team is already working on entering these news reports, but we can use help from half a dozen more hands. If you want to help, or know someone who does, or have a confusion about the reporting process that isn’t addressed on the reporting guide, write to Dipti (dipti.thuse@gmail.com) immediately.

Organization

We have reached out to National Election Watch and the Election Commission to involve them in the project. We are also speaking to some prominent people to form an advisory board for Vote Report India. We are still reaching out to civil society organizations to form more partnerships. If you have any suggestions on partnerships, please contact Satchit (satchitbalsari@gmail.com) immediately .

Buzz/ Promotion

In the short time we have been around, almost 70 blog posts have linked to us, as per Technorati. We also have a series of news stories and interviews lined up. I’ll update these stories in the press room as they appear. If you know any journalists or bloggers, please point them to the press room and ask them to do a story.

Also, do join the Vote Report India community at Twitter (@votereportindia), Facebook, Orkut, SMSGupShup or Google Groups and subscribe to our blog. If you have a blog or a website, please consider writing about Vote Report India and displaying our banners (200X200 and 150X150) on your blog or website.For details and clarifications, contact me (gauravonomics@gmail.com).

We have also tied up with several online partners for cross-promotion. These partnerships include Al Jazeera, LiveJournal, Global Voices, Indipepal, Desipundit, BlogAdda and NGO Post. Some of them have already put up our logos and feeds, some of them will do so today.

In Summary

In summary, we have had an exciting ten days on Vote Report India, and the excitement is only going to become more intense over the course of the elections.